NarrativeTherapyMichaelWhiteSocialConstructionismMentalHealthMountainViewTherapy

Who Gets to Define Failure?

“Never before has the sense of being a failure to be an adequate person been so freely available to people, and never before has it been so willingly and routinely dispensed.” — Michael White (2002), Addressing Personal Failure

Michael White, co-founder of Narrative Therapy, wrote this in 2002, and I can't help but think that the experience of failure has only become more available with the rise of social media and the growing expectation that we present ourselves as a brand. We're constantly invited to compare all the messiness and complexity of our own lives to carefully curated versions of other people's lives. In the process, what other people choose to show us can start to shape our ideas about what our own lives are supposed to look like. So many of my therapeutic conversations involve people struggling with the sense that they're failing to live up to expectations they feel obligated to meet.

But what does it actually mean to fail?

So often, we mistake judgments about who we should be for objective truths. Failure isn't possible without first having some standard or expectation that we believe we should be living up to.

This raises some interesting questions: Who gets to set the standards we're trying to meet? Who decides what counts as failure or success? Where do these expectations come from? Would they still matter if we lived in a different culture, community, or set of circumstances?

We can't understand what it means to fail without first understanding the expectations we're trying to live up to!

In Narrative Therapy, we're always thinking about how dominant stories shape the ways we understand ourselves. For example, if marriage is supposed to last forever, then divorce means we've failed. If good parents raise happy, successful children, then a child's struggles mean we're bad parents. Or if hard work leads to success, then not succeeding must mean we didn't work hard enough.

We're so steeped in these stories that they become taken-for-granted truths. As narrative therapists, we're interested in questioning these stories rather than automatically questioning a person's worth.

Even the expectations we understand as our own are shaped by our experiences in the world. Our values don't develop in isolation. They're influenced by our relationships, communities, cultures, and the stories we've been exposed to about what makes a good life. We might come to question some of these values, while developing a richer understanding of others and finding ways to hold them more closely.

When a person comes to understand themselves as a failure, an enormous amount of their life can be reduced to a thin description, a single conclusion about who they are. It can make their efforts, intentions, relationships, values, resistance, and the circumstances that contributed to this conclusion invisible.

A narrative therapist might become curious about how Failure gained the authority to define a person's identity. We might ask when Failure started telling this story, what experiences it uses as evidence, what experiences it has to leave out, who supports this story, and who stands against it!

Failure can also make invisible what people care about!

When a person experiences failure, it's often because something matters to them. When someone feels they've failed in a relationship, it might be because they're committed to love, intimacy, or mutual understanding. When someone feels they've failed as a parent, it might be because they value connection, care, and responsibility.

Experiences of failure can point us toward something a person holds dear or wants to protect. In Narrative Therapy, we can use these experiences to open up conversations about what's important to a person, rather than allowing Failure to define who they are.

But we might also become curious about the relationship between what someone values and the expectations they've developed around those values. Someone might deeply value being a caring parent while also believing that a good parent should raise a happy, successful child. Where did that expectation come from? Does it actually reflect what they value about parenting? And what happens when their child's experiences don't fit that expectation?

These conversations give people an opportunity to question expectations they've come to accept, develop a richer understanding of what matters to them, and consider how they want to live in relation to those values.

We also need to pay attention to how power shapes our experiences of failure. Failure tends to place responsibility on individuals while ignoring systemic inequalities, discrimination, economic conditions, disability, and unequal access to resources.

When we understand ourselves as failures, it doesn't just shape how we think about who we are. It also shapes what we believe needs to change. If someone understands their financial struggles as evidence that they haven't worked hard enough, they may spend their energy trying to correct their perceived shortcomings rather than questioning the economic circumstances that contribute to their struggles.

Our culture is full of stories that encourage us to understand failure as an individual problem. These stories become so familiar that we may not even recognize them as stories. They keep us busy examining what's wrong with ourselves rather than questioning the systems and institutions that shape our lives. Sometimes these stories are deliberately used to maintain existing power structures, but they don't require anyone's conscious intention to have that effect.

What we're encouraged to understand as personal failure may actually reflect the failures of those systems and institutions.

Of course, questioning these stories doesn't mean we stop living in a world shaped by them. Someone might reject the idea that their financial circumstances determine their worth, but they still have to navigate the very real consequences of economic inequality. We can't simply think our way out of these conditions. Questioning the judgments we've come to accept about ourselves can, however, change how we understand our circumstances and where we direct our efforts to create change.

Our goal as narrative therapists isn't to redefine everything as a success.

We can experience regret, disappointment, loss, and responsibility without allowing those experiences to become the stories that define us. The problem isn't necessarily the experience of failure, but the authority Failure gains to define who we are, who we should be, and how we should live.

We're not simply trying to help people feel better about failure. We're inviting people to question the systems of judgment that give Failure its authority over our lives, and to consider what becomes possible when we begin challenging that authority.

Check us out on Social Media